The Duncan Banner


September 27, 2012

Ruling leaves questions about compensation for wrongfully convicted man

DUNCAN — A Tulsa County judge on Thursday formally vacated a Comanche man’s armed robbery and burglary convictions that wrongfully sent him to prison for 16 years.

But the judge did not declare Sedrick Courtney’s actual innocence, one of his lawyers said.  

Attorneys for Courtney wanted the judge to make a finding of actual innocence, which could make it easier for Courtney to be compensated for his wrongful conviction and imprisonment. Oklahoma caps total state damages in such cases at $175,000.

David Loftis, an attorney for the Innocence Project representing Courntey, said it would have been better for the judge to have declared actual innocence. But he said the ruling does not necessarily preclude Courtney from being compensated.

“He has faith he will be compensated,” said Loftis, adding that the ruling is a “little bump in the road” toward that goal.

Courtney was convicted in 1996 and spent 16 years in prison before he was paroled in June 2011. Based on new DNA testing, the Tulsa  judge  – with consent from prosecutors – negated the conviction this past July.

That meant no further probation obligations for Courtney and wiped the felony from his record.

After he was paroled last year, Courtney met Tina Benedict of Comanche and they married last March. The couple lives in Comanche with Tina’s young son, Elijah, and Sedrick and Tina both work in Duncan.

The New York-based Innocence Project, which seeks to free wrongfully convicted inmates from prison, was instrumental in finding evidence that had earlier been declared lost in Courtney’s case and having it tested for DNA.  

The tests indicated that none of the hair samples from ski masks found near the crime in Tulsa matched those of Courtney.

More coverage on the case will be in Friday's edition of The Banner.

Text Only
Local News

The new Jimmy's Egg restaurant will be in the former Legacy Bank building on U.S. Highway 81 at West Club Road. The building is being renovated for the restaurant, which is scheduled to open June 9.

  • Governor, state Legislature have misplaced priorities

    If the Oklahoma State Legislators and our Governor spent less time interfering in women’s rights to manage their bodies, creating ways to lay more taxes and fees on the middle class in order to generate more tax breaks which benefit only the wealthy while also conceiving methods with which to fill Oklahoma’s for-profit prisons, they would be doing all of us a favor. Instead, why not work to enhance funding for our schools and wage increases for all school employees? While reforming the state’s educational budget, why don’t they approve wage increases for our Oklahoma State Troopers and enlarge their Academy to insure qualified individuals are ready to fill the upcoming vacancies as many of the older force retire?

    April 9, 2014

  • Self government key to keeping politicians in check

    Last week, the U.S. Supreme Court ruled 5-4 that federal campaign laws that limit the total amount of money donors can give to political parties, committees and candidates for federal office (U.S. House, Senate, and President) was unconstitutional. The ruling will not increase the current $2,600 limit on how much a donor can give to a federal candidate in each primary and general election or the $32,400 limit that can go to a national party committee. Those limits are still in place.  The ruling will instead remove the limit on how many candidates/committees to which a donor can contribute.

    April 9, 2014