The Duncan Banner


November 10, 2013

Accountability present in Duncan schools but not in current state evaluation model

DUNCAN — Accountability in Duncan Schools has always been a priority and transparency is one of the cornerstones for doing business in our district. In May of 2011, the Oklahoma Legislature passed H. B. 1456 to grade school performance on an A through F scale. At the time the law was passed, we did not completely understand the details of the grading system but fully intended to follow the law and embrace the evaluation model to improve student achievement. H.B. 1456 was intended to provide a system that would be useful to parents, educators, and students. It was to be a fair and equitable model that fairly assesses students through high stakes testing in grades 3 through 12. Unfortunately, the A-F grading system has failed to meet the intentions of the legislators responsible for the passage of HB 1456.

A testing debacle occurred in the spring of 2013 that negatively impacted our students testing experience. The testing company servers crashed, and students were “kicked off” the testing sites. The crash forced some students to completely start over while others were interrupted as long as three hours.

Because A-F grades are based on spring testing, educators and other professionals became frustrated and concerned about the affect this would have on overall school performance. Researchers from Oklahoma University and Oklahoma State University issued the following statement, “This year has borne witness to numerous testing protocol failures that corrupted the limited data used to calculate a grade for schools.” They further stated, “The data we have analyzed demonstrates quite dramatically that the letter grade system for school evaluation has very little meaning and certainly cannot be used to legitimately inform high-stakes decisions.”

On October 16th, Duncan Schools’ letter grades were issued. Since that time, our letter grades at each site have changed nine times. Some additional challenges we experienced include: cut scores in science and writing were changed after our students took the test, some students writing assessments have been re-graded, incorrect demographic information has been discovered, several reporting deadlines have been altered, and multiple testing messages from the Oklahoma State Department of Education have changed. In addition, OSDE informed districts they may send disputed writing tests back to the testing company to be graded a second time at a possible cost of $125/test.

Until research proves otherwise, I, as superintendent of Duncan Schools, will stand with OU/OSU researchers, professional organizations such as the Cooperative Council of School Administrators, and highly respected educators in our state and agree that the present accountability system is invalid, unreliable, and not relevant in assessing our students.

Sherry Labyer,

Duncan Superintendent


Text Only
  • Modern version of ‘Telephone’ hangs up on the truth

    Couple weeks ago, I stopped at a popular morning spot to get a caffeine infusion and encountered a meeting of a chapter of the Coffee Club Geniuses of America.

    July 20, 2014

  • taylor.armerding.jpg Zamperini, the Olympian and POW, was a hero because of his faith

    Louis Zamperini collected many accolades as an Olympic distance runner and brave bombardier who spent a month adrift at sea and two years in a Japanese prisoner of war camp. But faith and forgiveness are what truly distinguished him.

    July 18, 2014 1 Photo

  • Sheriff's helicopter could be put to good use in water crisis

    A story the other day in which Stephens County Sheriff Wayne McKinney explained the advantages of having a helicopter gave me a chuckle.

    July 15, 2014

  • Technoman offers help on combating viruses

    Good day, Earthlings and others inhabiting the third rock from the Sun. Once again, 21st Century Technoman has dropped in to see what condition your condition is in. So, how are you surviving in cyberspace?

    July 15, 2014

  • Territory impressive as well

    For the next seven days, the world of golf will focus on Edmond, Oklahoma in general and Oak Tree National in particular as the revitalized club and course hosts the prestigious 2014 U.S. Senior Open.

    July 6, 2014

  • Our division is not as dire as some insist

    Am having an Independence Day hangover — and no, it’s not because of any libation I may have consumed during the holiday weekend.

    July 6, 2014

  • Election shared few surprises

    There were no significant surprises or huge upsets in last Tuesday’s election,  but there were some twists and turns of interest locally and statewide.

    June 29, 2014

  • Other voices talk about us and our nation

    It’s almost Independence Day and I could wind philosophic and poetic about this country I love and into which I was lucky to have been randomly spawned.

    June 29, 2014

  • Technoman is relishing art of daydreaming

    Friends and neighbors, greetings again from 21st Century Technoman, and please forgive me if it seems I’ve been ignoring those of you who need a little human contact in their otherwise techno-dependent lives.

    June 22, 2014

  • However dubious, Cooter is a famous American

    His name is indelibly etched in the American experience. For generations, his reputation has crossed political, social, ethnic and regional lines.

    June 15, 2014


Should the date for The World's Largest Garage Sale be changed from the third weekend in July to sometime in October to take advantage of cooler weather like we had this past weekend?

No. It's better in the summer cause kids are out of school.
Yes. More shoppers would come during nice fall weather.
Either time is fine.

     View Results

Click HERE to read all your Parade favorites including Hollywood Wire, Celebrity interviews and photo galleries, Food recipes and cooking tips, Games and lots more.