The Duncan Banner

Local News

May 7, 2013

Property owners to foot the bill if $9m bond passes for road repairs

DUNCAN — When city officials in Duncan sought public approval to borrow money for a major street improvement effort in 2007, they gave voters two options to pay for it.

 One called for a $20 million bond to be paid through higher property taxes. The other would have funded the street work through a half-cent increase in the city’s sales tax rate.

A majority of voters balked at both of them.

Now, six years later, the city is asking voters to approve a $9 million general obligation bond that would be repaid over 10 years through additional taxes on property owners.

There is no sales-tax option this time, though some believe it would be the more equitable route to take because more people – not just property owners – would share in the debt burden.

“We need street repairs but that needs to be more of a shared responsibility,” said Peggy Davenport, an insurance agent in Duncan who helped defeat property tax bond issues sought by Duncan Public Schools in 2010 and 2011.

City officials, however, say their proposal makes financial sense on several levels.

The sales tax rate in Duncan is now 8.7 percent. It was 8.55 cents on the dollar before voters in Stephens County approved an additional 0.15 percent county-wide to provide more money for fire departments and senior nutrition centers.

The sales tax rate is still lower than the 8.88 percent in Lawton, but is higher than the 8.25 percent rate in Wichita Falls, Texas. Because of their size and proximity, those cities compete with Duncan for retail dollars.

Chris Deal, president of the Duncan Chamber of Commerce, said if sales taxes in Duncan go much higher, retailers here would take a hit because folks would shop for some products elsewhere. And that could mean less sales tax revenue for Duncan.

Proponents of the street proposal also say that bonds backed by property taxes draw better interest rates than those backed by sales taxes or utility payments. Property taxes are considered a more stable source of revenue because they are less susceptible to swings in the economy.

The average interest rate assumed on the proposed 10-year bond issue is 2.89 percent.

And because interest rates have remained at historically low levels for some time now, it’s a good time to borrow money.

It also makes sense to pay back the money over a 10-year term, city officials say, as opposed to doing it in five years or 15 years.

Allan Brooks, an attorney with Public Finance Law Group that is helping advise the city, explained that rationale to the Duncan City Council this way:

“If the term is too short, we were concerned about the debt burden,” Brooks said. “If the term was too long, we did not want to do street improvements that would be worn out before the debt was paid off.”

Under the proposal, the average additional tax on a house worth $150,000 would be about $98. That’s $8.17 more per month on average.

For a house worth $100,000, the annual tax bill would be about $64 higher. For one worth $250,000, it would be about $169.

Of the costs, $7.8 million would go toward construction, $943,000 for engineering and $176,000 – or 2 percent – for financing. The projections assume 3 percent for inflation.

Under the plan, only property owners – and perhaps some renters if landlords pass on the higher property taxes – would foot the bill.

And that bothers Davenport.

“This is something that the whole community benefits from and the streets need to be repaired, but at the same time we should all share in that,” she said.

Text Only
Local News
  • 4-20 bestinshow - carshow.jpg Gawkers and gearheads gather for car show on Main Street

    A fairly accurate timeline of the internal combustion engine was represented at the 7th Annual Cruisin’ the Chisolm Trail car show this weekend in dowtown Duncan.

    April 20, 2014 10 Photos

  • 4-20dragsterphoto.jpg Car show had a big bang this year

    Nothing at the previous car shows ever went kablooey quite like the featured vehicle at Cruisin’ the Chisolm Trail’s opening night on Friday.

    April 20, 2014 1 Photo

  • Inaugural prayer breakfast in Duncan patterned after National Day of Prayer

    A new tradition will begin in Duncan on May 1 -- an annual Mayor’s Prayer Breakfast.

    April 20, 2014

  • The Well Outreach plans mentoring program for kids at risk

    The Well Outreach, Inc., will unveil its plans for an in-school mentoring program it will launch this fall during a Tuesday night meeting at its 913 W. Main Street storefront.

    April 20, 2014

  • Bench murder trial to be returned to August docket

    Although the first-degree murder trial for Miles Bench has been set to begin Monday, District Attorney Jason Hicks said the trial is unlikely to begin before August.

    April 20, 2014

  • Bench found competent, trial to start Monday

    A jury took 50 minutes on Thursday to find Miles Sterling Bench competent to stand trial for first-degree murder  and District Judge Joe Enos scheduled the trial to begin Monday.
    Bench, 23, of, Velma, is accused of the bludgeoning death of 16-year-old Braylee Henry of Velma. She was killed in June 2012 in the Teepee Totem convenience store in Velma where Bench was employed.

    April 18, 2014

  • 4-18 Miller and Decathlon 0016.jpg Miller pumps up decathlon students

    Dr. Ché Miller, who helped bridge a funding gap needed to send the Duncan High School Decathlon Team to the national competition in Hawaii, gave the team a pep talk on Thursday.
    Miller, recently recognized as the Man of the Year by the Duncan Chamber of Commerce and Industry, told the students they are about to embark on a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity and advised them to absorb as much of the experience as they can.

    April 18, 2014 1 Photo

  • Churches prepare for Easter Sunday

    Churches throughout Duncan and Stephens County are preparing to celebrate Easter this Sunday, the day Christians celebrate the ascension of Jesus Christ into heaven.
    Today is known as Good Friday to mark the day Christ was crucified on a cross.

    April 18, 2014

  • 4-18 lauren-ellis mug.jpg Ellis named new CEO of regional United Way

    Lauren Ellis, who’s led the United Way of Stephens County for more than two years, has been named the new chief executive officer of the United Way of Southwest Oklahoma.
    Her new job will be based in Lawton but Ellis said she will remain in Duncan and commute.

    April 18, 2014 1 Photo

  • Jurors to decide Bench competency issue today

    Jurors will hear final arguments on Thursday and then be asked to determine whether  23-year-old Miles Sterling Bench is mentally competent to stand trial for first-degree murder in the bludgeoning death of 16-year-old Braylee Henry nearly two years ago.

    April 17, 2014